A cluster of residents residing in the Upper Beaches neighborhood is expressing frustration over the smoke emanating from a nearby restaurant, with limited avenues for local authorities to intervene. The residents are complaining about the pervasive smoke and fumes originating from the Beach Hill Smokehouse on Main Street at Gerrard Street E., which has been in operation for approximately eight years, making it challenging for them to enjoy their outdoor spaces.
Kevin Lacombe, a resident living behind the restaurant, shared, “It’s impossible to spend time outdoors due to the overwhelming smoke that irritates the eyes and throat.” In response to the issue, 78 residents have signed a petition urging both local and provincial authorities to address the emissions matter.
Despite the complaints, city officials indicate that there may be minimal actions that can be taken as the restaurant owner, Darien List, seems to be adhering to Toronto Public Health regulations. Following a recent inspection in May 2023 prompted by odor complaints, the establishment was found to be in compliance with relevant municipal bylaws.
Videos and images provided to CBC Toronto depict a cloud of smoke enveloping the area behind the restaurant, which includes townhomes, apartments, and detached homes. Residents report that smoking incidents occur several times a week lasting around 20 to 30 minutes each time, a claim corroborated by List.
List stated that he is puzzled by the residents’ grievances, emphasizing his compliance with all inspections and regulations set forth by the city. Meanwhile, Guillermo Gabrielli, who initiated the petition, is urging List to install a filter on the smokestack to mitigate the smoke and potentially harmful emissions.
City Councilor Brad Bradford acknowledges the residents’ concerns but notes that the restaurant is operating within the legal framework. He suggests that the issues raised by the residents could be an inherent consequence of living in a bustling urban environment.
While some passersby find the smoke bearable, others observe thick smoke extending for a block at times. Despite residents’ concerns about potential health hazards, the Ministry of the Environment deferred inquiries back to the city, which affirmed no violations have been identified regarding the emissions from the smokestack.