Shane Slade cherishes the memories of his summer visits to Belle Isle during the 1980s and early 1990s. Accompanied by his father, they would journey annually to the secluded island situated at the eastern entrance of the Strait of Belle Isle, nestled between Labrador and Newfoundland, to engage in cod fishing. Recalling those carefree summers, Slade, who now serves as the mayor of Lushes Bight-Beaumont-Beaumont North, described the tranquility, absence of noise, and the joy of fishing with his father.
In the past, Belle Isle attracted several families who sought solace on the island, renowned for its trio of lighthouses: the Belle Isle Northeast Lighthouse, the Belle Isle South End Lower Lighthouse, and the Belle Isle South End Upper Lighthouse. Presently, there is a stark contrast as no one frequents Belle Isle for summer fishing expeditions, and the lighthouses stand unstaffed.
After a 35-year hiatus, Slade fulfilled his long-standing desire to revisit Belle Isle in August, reliving cherished childhood moments. While the overall experience was positive, a troubling discovery at the northeast end drew his attention. He encountered abandoned demolition materials left in deteriorating bags, highlighting neglect and decay on the island.
Expressing disappointment at the current state of Belle Isle, Slade emphasized the need for immediate action to rectify the situation. He pointed out the deteriorating bags containing demolition debris that now require re-bagging for removal. Additionally, despite not being able to personally inspect the south end dwelling, the remaining structure showcased deplorable conditions with scattered debris and signs of neglect.
Slade’s sentiments are echoed by Monica Campbell, a former resident of Belle Isle, whose father served as a lightkeeper on the island in the 1980s. Campbell, like Slade, expressed dismay at the government’s inaction towards preserving the historical significance of Belle Isle, emphasizing the importance of maintaining and respecting the island’s heritage.
Addressing the concerns raised by Slade and others, National Defence, under which the Canadian Coast Guard operates, confirmed its responsibility for managing the remaining demolition materials on Belle Isle. The demolition process, which commenced in 2017, involved the removal of various structures and infrastructure elements, with plans to eventually clear the remaining debris. Notably, the dwelling on the southwest end is safeguarded under the Heritage Lighthouse Protection Act, with efforts underway to refurbish the structure.
As stakeholders advocate for the preservation and restoration of Belle Isle’s cultural heritage, the need for prompt government intervention and proactive measures to address the island’s deteriorating condition remains a pressing concern.